How do you know either of these are true?

first she disappears into nothing after she starts bleeding. if u go back into the room there isnt a single drop of blood. any where. dont you find that odd? also when lisa pulls kauffman down at the end. a dead person cant come back to life. its impossible. shes a memory that has been projected into the physiological world.

Living people teleport around Silent Hill without leaving behind blood ALL THE TIME, and...well, if a DEAD person can't come to life, who can? Living people coming back to life is redundant.

Also lol Maria.

your right they do. but thats not proving when lisa died. adversary has an exact date. yet he fails to PROVE it. it seems its easier to just let other people figure things out, even when theres no evidence. im not gonna apologize for questioning things.

We see her alive in the opening cinema, the narrative of which is all occurring at or around the same time: Harry driving to town, Cybil dispatching from Brahms, M.K. arguing with Lisa. The game begins immediately afterward, and, during the events of the game, Lisa dies. The game, according to Silent Hill: Play Novel, takes place on April 20th.

Thus: Lisa dies on April 20th, 1980.

Jesus H. Christ. . . .

wait..so u add in the play novel to the timeline, but not shattered memories

Silent Hill: Shattered Memories is not at all part of the series' continuity, nor can it possibly be integrated into the series.

Seriously. Have you ever played a Silent Hill game? or do you just read about them and guess?

ive played silent hill, silent hill 2, 3, 4, homecoming, origins and currently shattered memories.

Well, if you haven't played the Play Novel, you're in no place to be an asshole and criticize Adversary. It's not like his timeline doesn't have citations in it.

your right. sorry adversary. what system is it for?

GBA.

Hope your Japanese is good.

There's partial patches on the internet.

You can find some of the Play Novel here.

I'm sure I'm just missing it, and it's not really something major, per se, but why is Jennifer Carol's burning not on this?
Again, it's something very small, but I just figured it be there.

I'm pretty sure that no specific year is mentioned for Jennifer Carrol anywhere in the games or supplementary materials. All we know is that Christians martyred her sometime in the past.

^I must've been mistaken.
I thought they'd mentioned it in the first or third game.

Jennifer Carrol was not mentioned at all in-game for SH1. She was only mentioned in SH2 and SH3, I believe. I think there is some information about her in the guidebooks, but she is such a minor character in game, although someone said something about Jennifer Carrol being in Homecoming, but I wouldn't know.

I've debated not posting this cause it's so minor and I feel like an just writing this....

Something I'm confused about, this is regarding Claudia's age. I know this is probably
the most anal post, and lol I'm really not trying to nitpick...
(Lisa was included because I was trying to figure something else out before.)

Silent hill takes place in 1980(according to this time-line)

The events of Silent Hill Origins occur during Alessa's burning.

During Alessa's burning Lisa is 16, Alessa is 7.(1973)

7 years after Alessa is burned Silent hill 1 takes place.

Lisa is 23, Alessa is 14.(Cheryl is 7, Heather is born) - 1980

At this point we know Lisa is no longer alive.

[Making Lisa born in 1957]
[Making Alessa born in 1966]
[Making Claudia Born in 1968]
[Making Cheryl born in 1973]
[Making Heather Born in 1980]

1985 Harry kills a "perpetrator" in Portland

(Somewhere between Portland and SH2 Vincent expands the Church)
(Somewhere between Portland and Sh3 James goes to Silent Hill) (according to this time-line 1994)

1997 Silent hill 3 Takes place.
Lisa would have been 40, Alessa 31, Cheryl 24. Heather is 17, and Claudia 29.
(I haven't read anywhere it claiming her to be 30 years old)


... I know it's such a very little thing, but even if Alessa was born on
1/1/1966 and Claudia was born 12/12/1967 they'd still be a day off two years so,
wouldn't it be more likely she was born in 68'?

And just out of curiosity...(sh3 IG event)

At the point she said that, she didn't remember yet.
So...