Why was Christabella killed in that oh so special way?

Post by **Tobor** » 25 Aug 2008

I believe she was killed that way because alessa wanted to shed her of her "purity", in a sense.

or could it have been because Gans wanted a super violent revenge scene for the audience?

Post by **LanceS133** » 25 Aug 2008

I'm going with Option A.

Post by **blank fairy** » 25 Aug 2008

I think Alessa did it as a response to Christabella's babbling about staying pure and all that jazz.

Post by **Tobor** » 25 Aug 2008

blank fairy wrote:I think Alessa did it as a response to Christabella's babbling about staying pure and all that jazz.

thats what i figured.

Post by **JKristine35** » 26 Aug 2008

Alessa did it because Christabella never helped her even as she screamed while being raped by the janitor. It may also deal with purity, but there are too many symbolisms in the film pointing to Alessa's rape to ignore that.

Post by **LanceS133** » 26 Aug 2008

True, combo of both then?

Post by **Tobor** » 26 Aug 2008

i dont know if alessa was "raped' i think she was definitely molested though.

And that is a really good point. Almost like payback, or "heres how this felt".

If thats the case, maybe she was raped. :/

Post by **AuraTwilight** » 26 Aug 2008

Pretty much all the answers here are right.

i dont know if alessa was "raped' i think she was definitely molested though.

Is there a difference? Unless you're implying that Alessa was totally getting down with Colin all giddy-like, it was rape.

Post by **Tobor** » 26 Aug 2008

AuraTwilight wrote:Pretty much all the answers here are right.

i dont know if alessa was "raped' i think she was definitely molested though.
Is there a difference? Unless you're implying that Alessa was totally getting down with Colin all giddy-like, it was rape.

No, rape is forced penetration, molestation is unwanted fondling of genitalia.

Post by **Nasta** » 26 Aug 2008

The difference is pretty much only semantics.

Post by **Tobor** » 26 Aug 2008

Either way! she was violated haha

Post by **JKristine35** » 27 Aug 2008

I think the scene where PH thrusts his massive sword through the door at Rose and Cybil strongly implies that Alessa was indeed raped.

Post by **Tobor** » 27 Aug 2008

JRamirez35 wrote:I think the scene where PH thrusts his massive sword through the door at Rose and Cybil strongly implies that Alessa was indeed raped.

WHOA! i never even thought of that. Thats a really good analysis.

Post by **Shoot The Sky** » 27 Aug 2008

I actually just noticed right before it happens, she says "God be with me" insignifigant, but I didnt notice that the first 10 times of seeing the movie

Mockingbird wrote:Because she was a raging c*nt.

oooooooooo not cool guy... not cool

I think the scene where PH thrusts his massive sword through the door at Rose and Cybil strongly implies that Alessa was indeed raped.

hmm and maybe him twisting the knife meant... you know... him like... ripping her so to speak? widening her?......................awkward
and the bugs are like... sperms?........................*long silence*
Or maybe he just wanted to cut 'em...

uhh.... Ill be leaving now
byez!

Post by **Tobor** » 27 Aug 2008

Shoot The Sky wrote:I actually just noticed right before it happens, she says "God be with me" insignifigant, but I didnt notice that the first 10 times of seeing the movie

Mockingbird wrote:Because she was a raging c*nt.
oooooooooo not cool guy... not cool

I think the scene where PH thrusts his massive sword through the door at Rose and Cybil strongly implies that Alessa was indeed raped.
hmm and maybe him twisting the knife meant... you know... him like... ripping her so to speak? widening her?......................awkward
and the bugs are like... sperms?........................*long silence*
uhh.... Ill be leaving now
byez!

I know your analysis may be a bit out there, but i can see where your coming from, i dont thin they would symbolize that much though. We are talking about a child.

Post by **Shoot The Sky** » 27 Aug 2008

thats why I added "or maybe he just wants to cut em"

Im guessing thats the point there

Us SH lovers always try to look deeper into things.

Post by **Tobor** » 27 Aug 2008

Haha, thats what makes us different than the other video gamers out there.;]

Schism · Post by **Schism** » 31 Aug 2008

she basically raped the sh*t out of her with the wire.

BlackFire · Post by **BlackFire** » 04 Sep 2008

I guess it might have to do with that purity thing, but, I was kinda just thinking that it was pretty much just intended to be a violent death.
Although, that purity thing is a good possibility.

JRamirez35 wrote:I think the scene where PH thrusts his massive sword through the door at Rose and Cybil strongly implies that Alessa was indeed raped.

Honestly, I think that's just a ridiculous thing to say. Do you really think that by merely shoving a big knife through a door to kill them, that it was supposed to symbolize that, or anything even?
Uhhh, he's trying to kill them.

You might as well say that when some nurse is carrying a big steel pipe around, that's supposed to symbolize...you know.

USE THE EDIT BUTTON! Do not double OR triple post!

Post by **crucifix** » 04 Sep 2008

Shoot The Sky wrote:kind of a bit disrespectfull to say that

don't speak for all females on that, because "c*nt" is one of my favorite insults.

anyway, implying that alessa was raped is ludicrous. i've said it before - you guys would make freud jealous with your theories.