looks like we have a winner
EDIT: here is what they said
"At last, after the naff nonsence that was Lara Croft, Doom and Resident Evil, a movie adapted from a computer game that isnt bad.
In fact it's pretty damn good, mainly because director Christopher Gans - the bloke behind weird french horror the brotherhood of the wolves isnt afraid to mess with the franchise. So instead of an Arnold Schwarzenegger style hero trying to save a missing child from a bunch of ghosts, you get a mother trying to track down her missing and terminally ill daughter.
The film doesnt stint on action, with mum Radha Mitchell, from Pitch Black, and cop Laurie Holden kicking some serious butt. Sean Bean also stars as the missing girls dad.
Theres plenty of gore and big scares, especially when the mum has to creep through a nightmareish hospital staffed by bandage clad killer nurses.
It's enough to make you wish you'd gone private!
4/5 stars"
