This problem child is beginning to frustrate me. Is it so wrong to provide fans of the series with information regarding to certains details...?
, Gwilym seems seriously upset I put the soundtrack list on there...
Isn't it good to be able to communicate this level of depth though? In case of people wondering "What was that song at [x]?" -- comment made by Cipher Destiny, added by captbananas
I don't think so. If Wikipedia had an entry for every special interest sub-topic (particularly involving music use in various media), the entire world would probably collapse under its own weight. If anything, it should be an external link. --Gwilym 10:45, 23 April 2006 (UTC)
It's unneccessary. No other films do this, unless the music is part of the story (and even then, they never say where each track appeared.
It could (should) easily be trimmed down to saying that the soundtrack is mostly a collection of slightly modified versions of tracks from the games, plus the Johnny Cash song.--Gwilym 21:23, 22 April 2006 (UTC)
I think the only reason people who have got to see it (NOT ME YET!) have added this excessive information if because most fans were foaming at the mouth to find out if Akira Yamaoka would be scoring the movie or not. And while I can understand why some would want this information available, it is definatly not necessary and I agree with what you say Gwilym. It should definatly be edited down only to include mention that Yamaoka's music was in fact included, the Johnny Cash song is in there, and thats about it. captbananas 02:33, 23 April 2006 (UTC)
Also of note Cipher Destiny, please sign your talk comments and add your input to the end of the conversation so as not to flub up the flow of what is already there. Thank you. captbananas 18:13, 23 April 2006 (UTC)
I disagree I think the detailed information is useful for people who want to assemble their own version of the soundtrack using the various Silent Hill OST's
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia: ... nformation
I really think this is going against #2 and #8.--Gwilym 22:28, 23 April 2006 (UTC)
I'm just a reader, not an editor, (or a gamer) but I found the soundtrack listing very useful. Please leave it in. ~IMP
I inserted the soundtrack as a means for fans of both the game and movie to know the names of the tracks. I did this for the sake of information, not as an excuse for people to go and illegally download these songs. As a long-time and devoted fan of the game and a fan of the film, I did this because other fans would find the information useful. According to :Christophe Gans:, there won't be a soundtrack to film though this may only be speculation. I understand your disappointment, Gwilym, but I did this for other fans' curiousity and for information regarding the soundtrack. There aren't any spoilers in the descriptions other than what certain characters are doing. So, please relax, this is a site based on providing users and visitors with information. -Fever_Chill