I am lost between Dhalia and Claudia!!

[Raider Man]

First! We met Dhalia in SH1 who we discovered that Dhalia is alessa's mother, so that Chyrl is also Dhalia's daughter, but then when SH3 released, all the story had been mixed up, for the Good ending in SH1, Alessa reborn a baby and gave it to Harry, in SH3, Vincent said the Claudia is Heather's mother, but Heather is Chyrl and Alessa (She have 3 names, and I solved the ages puzzle it's easy, that's why they talked about her birthday) But what about Cluadia, is she Alessa? Are they making the same story as the Walter man and the Walter kid?! But Heather is Alessa, But Claudia is her mother, but Alessa is her mother, but Alessa is herself, what about Dhalia? 2 mothers?

I am lost, please anybody explain to me... And thank you!

[cascade88]

Unless I'm crazy, Vincent never said that Clauida is Heather's mother...

[AgentX7k]

for the Good ending in SH1, Alessa reborn a baby and gave it to Harry, in SH3

Actually that was God who gave the baby to Harry, which is Heather (Alessa + Cheryl).

in SH3, Vincent said the Claudia is Heather's mother

He said that Dahlia was her mother, he said Claudia was brainwashed by that crazy old hag (meaning Dahlia).

But what about Cluadia, is she Alessa? Are they making the same story as the Walter man and the Walter kid?! But Heather is Alessa, But Claudia is her mother, but Alessa is her mother, but Alessa is herself, what about Dhalia? 2 mothers?!

Claudia is Alessa's childhood friend, they thought of each other as sisters. They have no blood relation.

[Video Gamer]

Cascade's right...I don't recall hearing Vincent say anything of this sort.

[AgentX7k]

He didn't really, Raider_Man was just confused by this line: "You mean Claudia? Please don't lump me together with her! She was totally brainwashed by that crazy old hag ... well crazy old hag is a bit harsh, she is your mother afterall."

[cascade88]

So I see. Guess it could be confusing then. But yeah, when Vincent said hag, he meant Dahlia, not Claudia.

[Scarlet]

Oh dear... you are really confused... But I guess Agent explained almost everything...

[Raider Man]

Speical thanks to you Agent! I didn't know that he was talking about Dhalia, at least he must mention her name, LOL! anyway, thanks.

[Revolutionlost]

Vincent was reffering to Dahlia when he states "She is your mother, afterall." He was talking about how crazy he thought Dahlia was, not Claudia.
At first I thought he was talking about Claudia, but I listened closer and realized the reference was to Dahlia.

[alone in the town]

Just FYI, while I don't think it's specifically against the rules to bump a thread from 18 months ago to answer a question which has already been answered, it's one of those things which is definitely frowned-upon.

[Magnolia]

Mother of one's former body is still their mother? That's a hell of a lot of mothers.