Silent Hill Heaven
http://silenthillforum.com/

Where it all began !!!!
http://silenthillforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=26258
Page 1 of 1

Author:  Fantam39 [ 20 Mar 2017 ]
Post subject:  Where it all began !!!!

I was watching Silent Hill the movie and it captured the feel of the first game really well the way Rose crashes the car because Gillespie as a young girl was in the middle of the road and even the ally way scene was like when Harry went looking for Cheryl, I didn't know the order was apart of the cult till the end of the movie. Fantam 39 posted 20/03/17.

Author:  HeartlessBastard [ 18 Apr 2017 ]
Post subject:  Re: Where it all began !!!!

Silent Hill Rule #21
Forget the movies if you want to know the series.

Author:  Midori-chan [ 08 May 2017 ]
Post subject:  Re: Where it all began !!!!

Honestly. But no, the movies were such an abomination I hate to think that I ever watched them in the first place.

Author:  Mephisto [ 08 May 2017 ]
Post subject:  Re: Where it all began !!!!

I thought the movies were alright, to be honest. Don't forget that they're based on the games so don't expect everything to be the same.

Author:  Kenji [ 09 May 2017 ]
Post subject:  Re: Where it all began !!!!

The first movie was okay, and I wish there was a director's cut for all that missing content, 'cuz I'm fairly interested in what Gans wanted that the studio didn't.

The second movie is an abomination. I regret letting my sister talk me into watching it.

Now that we're at this point in the franchise, I'd be highly amused if a third movie came out that was based on one of the later games and handed it its ass.

Author:  J. Quinzelle [ 21 Jun 2017 ]
Post subject:  Re: Where it all began !!!!

Kenji wrote:
Now that we're at this point in the franchise, I'd be highly amused if a third movie came out that was based on one of the later games and handed it its ass.


It's what I'm trying to accomplish. A Silent Hill movie that makes up for Revelations' being such a crap movie. At least the first one had atmosphere.

I wish there was a way the Silent Hill community could support my efforts and get this paper out there.

Author:  mikefile [ 26 Jun 2017 ]
Post subject:  Re: Where it all began !!!!

When I first saw Gans' movie, I was disappointed. The atmosphere was epic, but it didn't capture the soul of the first game (or the series). But with time, that started to change. The more I watched the movie, the more I fell in love with it.. because I understood that it had its own soul and that I was using the wrong approach the whole time. Regardless first appearances, the story in itself is very different from the first game, thus it has its own rules and motivations. It's funny how with time it became one of my top favorites.

To sum up, in regards to Rule #21 mentioned by a member earlier, we shouldn't forget (reversed #21) Rule #22: "Forget the series if you want to know the movie."

*Notice how I wrote movie, not movieS, as nothing will ever help you understand Revelation since that garbage makes no fucking sense whatsoever.

Author:  Alexius Corvinus [ 02 Jul 2017 ]
Post subject:  Re: Where it all began !!!!

Watched the first Silent Hill movie with a mate unfamiliar with the series. We saw it when it was first released in the theaters. It pained me to see how awful the movie was compared to the games, as my friend had the wrong impression about the series as a whole. When the entire theater erupts in laughter in several scenes, you know you have an accidental comedy on your hands.

As far as I can rember in the games, the Order was never a Christian sect or cult. Yet in the first movie, the references to Christianity was so on the nose. Although I wouldn't call myself a bible toting Christian (for certain reasons), I think the blanket criticism of an entire religion could have been done in a more tasteful way. Just my opinion though.

Author:  Jonipoon [ 24 Sep 2017 ]
Post subject:  Re: Where it all began !!!!

Actually, the first movie was fine by itself until Double Helix Games decided to copy its Otherworld transitions into Homecoming. So, the movie is partly to blame for that...

On the other hand, I don't really consider anything post-The Room to be part of the series anyway. Origins fucked up many major events, Homecoming AKA Saw 5 was just atrocious, Shattered Memories is silly even though it is its own thing, and Downpour was a nice try that didn't deliver.

Author:  phantomess [ 04 Oct 2017 ]
Post subject:  Re: Where it all began !!!!

I actually enjoyed the first movie quite a bit. I saw it in theatres THREE times opening weekend, and still watch it occasionally. Certainly there are things I'm less than fond of: the cult scenes (that's quite a bit, I know, lol), Alessa's portrayal (and yet I had Jodelle sign a SH movie poster, lol again), the stupid explanation scene, the fact that they killed my favorite character in a fucking terrible way... But I enjoy the atmosphere, environments, monsters, and music throughout so much of the movie that I can't help having some level of respect for it. Plus I shamelessly enjoyed the moments of fan service, like the alley scene (she even ran into the barrel!!).
I do think it was a decent Silent Hill movie in a number of important aspects. Sure, it can't really measure up to the games, but it made a pretty amazing effort for a movie.

Revelations, on the other hand, I still have not watched a second time. I keep thinking I will one of these days, and wonder if I'll like it somewhat more the second time, but... I dunno. I remember there being some moments I liked, but on the whole, it was quite bad.

Should this thread be in the movie section?

Author:  J. Quinzelle [ 15 Oct 2017 ]
Post subject:  Re: Where it all began !!!!

I liked the first film, didn't love it. I found the atmosphere to be near perfect in replication. But the script was severely lacking a lot. Poor dialogue, odd character choices, and the idea to turn it into a witch hunt? What was Avery thinking. I liked turning Harry into Rose, hated Gans reasoning for it. As time went on, I watched it countless times. It's often playing in the background when I'm playing on my Vita or writing. It's my favorite video game movie now.

Now, Silent Hill Revelations... That was crap.

Page 1 of 1 All times are UTC [ DST ]
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/