Is there any truth to this? Any sources? Thoughts? Because this is the first time I've heard about it. Personally, I'm conflicted. On one hand, Silent Hill 2 is my favorite game and the ambiguous nature of its ending only makes me like it that much more. Even with the ambiguity, it still feels like whatever ending you get provides more than enough closure that would make any attempts at a direct sequel unnecessary. But on the other, it might have been better than what Homecoming ended up being.i think in the 2007 game silent hill home coming they actually did though about bringing James back , they were originally going to make the lead female an older Laura the love interest of the main protagonist , i think James in that had remarried and might have been unframed for any murder since female leads mother is a judge so she must have used her connection to coverup Mary's murder.
EDIT: Turns out it's true. Found it on the Silent Hill Wiki page.