Writing my dissertation on Silent Hill 2!
Moderator: Moderators
Writing my dissertation on Silent Hill 2!
Hi folks! New to the forum, have recently decided to write my dissertation on the game silent hill 2 to prove once and for all that games can constitute narratives.
If anyone has anything to say about the narrative in SH2 pleas please post, I am loving everyones opinions and also if you know anything about joseph campbell and the heros journey and you can apply your points to this, extra marks for you!
If anyone has anything to say about the narrative in SH2 pleas please post, I am loving everyones opinions and also if you know anything about joseph campbell and the heros journey and you can apply your points to this, extra marks for you!
- NightFlutter
- Hope House Careworker
- Posts: 698
- Joined: 30 Mar 2005
- Location: Everett, MA
- Contact:
Joseph Campbell? I'm confused...but kudos to you for writing a disscertation on SH. I did my last 2 English finals on it. Go you!
[url=http://www.myspace.com/unknown_monkeyman][img]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v608/ForgotAboutDre/My%20Creations/Sigs/SigPro.jpg[/img][/url]
[i]“Standing above the crowd...he had a voice that was strong and loud."[/i]
[i]“Standing above the crowd...he had a voice that was strong and loud."[/i]
- Chronic Victim
- Woodside Apartments Janitor
- Posts: 1171
- Joined: 15 Jan 2005
- Location: Not here.
- NightFlutter
- Hope House Careworker
- Posts: 698
- Joined: 30 Mar 2005
- Location: Everett, MA
- Contact:
No I think the Joseph Campbell Hero's Journey thing was in reference to something else...
[url=http://www.myspace.com/unknown_monkeyman][img]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v608/ForgotAboutDre/My%20Creations/Sigs/SigPro.jpg[/img][/url]
[i]“Standing above the crowd...he had a voice that was strong and loud."[/i]
[i]“Standing above the crowd...he had a voice that was strong and loud."[/i]
ok lets do this...
i want to prove that a game can be a narrative, various dimwit academics have said they can't, for various dimwit reasons such as:
a narrative has to be a re-telling
there is no character acting in games
games do not ask you to suspend your belief
so any point that refers to sh having a clear narrative is good news
this heros journey lark goes like so:
the hero is called to action
there is a possible refusal of the call
the hero faces lots of little trails
he faces a godess
he faces atonement with the father
and lo and behold he comes through/ dies and is in some way a bit of a hero
for this he either gets to live/ bring some sort of prize or justice home/ be a master of two worlds...
in a nutshell, as i am feeling particularly tired and hungry today
a narrative has to be a re-telling
there is no character acting in games
games do not ask you to suspend your belief
so any point that refers to sh having a clear narrative is good news
this heros journey lark goes like so:
the hero is called to action
there is a possible refusal of the call
the hero faces lots of little trails
he faces a godess
he faces atonement with the father
and lo and behold he comes through/ dies and is in some way a bit of a hero
for this he either gets to live/ bring some sort of prize or justice home/ be a master of two worlds...
in a nutshell, as i am feeling particularly tired and hungry today
- NightFlutter
- Hope House Careworker
- Posts: 698
- Joined: 30 Mar 2005
- Location: Everett, MA
- Contact:
Re: ok lets do this...
Then why bother? If you ask me, you're risking grades to prove nothing anyone besides us cares about.eggwhite wrote:i want to prove that a game can be a narrative, various dimwit academics have said they can't, for various dimwit reasons
- Arthemesic
- Historical Society Historian
- Posts: 1868
- Joined: 11 Jun 2005
- Gender: Male
- Location: Finland
lolKnightWolfe wrote:A heros journey? James wasn't really on a heros journey. It was more of a kill stuff with a stick journey.
I hope that was a joke.
If it wasn't, I can ask you, do you skip all the story progression parts?
If you have seriously played the game without skipping cutscenes and reading/listening the lines well, you cannot say either of those "journeys". James wasn't there to kill stuff. He was there to find Mary. Nothing else. Either you made a great joke or I'm taking it seriously
Victory Of The Soul, Triumph Over Ordeal
- BloodyBunny
- Cafe5to2 Waitress
- Posts: 200
- Joined: 27 Sep 2005
- Location: New Hampshire
- Contact:
The hero's journey does indeed fit with Silent Hill (Everyone of them actualy). The problem being that The Hero's journey is almost so vague that it can really be applied to anything, like my journey to get a sandwhich this morning.
J.C. had some good points in "Hero with a Thousand Faces" (if you've read it), but one of his greatest points was the universiality of his theory. It applies to everything. So it's a good thing that his theory wasen't purely based off of applying it to life because it would have been like saying all living creatures are living. Instead he focused more on making his book a comparitive of the similarities of the Hero's Journey story in each culture, from Beowolf to Star Wars (which he actualy helped George Lucas put together...at least the first three which in fact is why the three newer ones lack the same flare.)
Anyway, I've said my piece. I wouldn't risk my grade, unless you have an understanding teacher who relishes in new, abstract ideas.
J.C. had some good points in "Hero with a Thousand Faces" (if you've read it), but one of his greatest points was the universiality of his theory. It applies to everything. So it's a good thing that his theory wasen't purely based off of applying it to life because it would have been like saying all living creatures are living. Instead he focused more on making his book a comparitive of the similarities of the Hero's Journey story in each culture, from Beowolf to Star Wars (which he actualy helped George Lucas put together...at least the first three which in fact is why the three newer ones lack the same flare.)
Anyway, I've said my piece. I wouldn't risk my grade, unless you have an understanding teacher who relishes in new, abstract ideas.
The fact that you physically control it's pace and branches doesn't change the fact that it's a story - that's just mechanics. I'm not sure how anyone can reasonably argue that it's not a narrative. Probably they assume it's like, Mario Bros. or something.dictionary.com wrote: Narrative:
A narrated account; a story.
The art, technique, or process of narrating.
If you lay out a very thorough and backed-up argument (citations to the many, many theories abound out here on ye olde 'net), I wouldn't think it's a very great risk at all. In the same way that your Hero's Journey follows a pretty clear story arc, so does SH. Hell you can almost draw straight lines from each plot point to the other.
Re: ok lets do this...
...yeah but James is really more of an anti-hero. He's called to action...sure... the letter calls him. Refusal? There's a slight questioning in the beginning...and then of course there's his refusal to remember the truth. Little trials? Yeah, many. He faces a Godess? Nay. No godesses here, friend.eggwhite wrote: this heros journey lark goes like so:
the hero is called to action
there is a possible refusal of the call
the hero faces lots of little trails
he faces a godess
he faces atonement with the father
and lo and behold he comes through/ dies and is in some way a bit of a hero
for this he either gets to live/ bring some sort of prize or justice home/ be a master of two worlds
All theories put aside, I still wouldn't put James up as a hero. He doesn't save anything...in fact...he doesn't accomplish much of anything. He forgot he did something within the recent past, and he faced many many trials to remember it. That's about it. There's no saving the day, there's no prize, there's no heroism. James is mearly a protagonist, by no means a hero.
And the last one... that depends on the ending you get. He might not get to live at all! Bwahahahaha!
This space intentionally left blank.
He saves his soul, perhaps. Atoned. (Yes, there are endings where that doesn't really happen, but you catch my drift.) Anti-heroes still count I would think.
But really the point I suspect is not necessarily to draw straight lines (tho I'd still argue that you could), but to draw parallels that illustrate that the story arc is just as complex and plot driven as any novel. It doesn't really matter which path you take in the game, the parallel remains (whether immediate and applied, or theoretically with some moderate linguistic gymnastics).
But really the point I suspect is not necessarily to draw straight lines (tho I'd still argue that you could), but to draw parallels that illustrate that the story arc is just as complex and plot driven as any novel. It doesn't really matter which path you take in the game, the parallel remains (whether immediate and applied, or theoretically with some moderate linguistic gymnastics).
-
- Woodside Apartments Janitor
- Posts: 1123
- Joined: 16 Dec 2005
- Location: Wherever Mother Claudia sends me.