[SPOILER] Cheryl is actually...?

Post by **simeonalo** » 06 Dec 2009

At the end of SH3, didn't Heather say that she was going to go by Cheryl, and that she would go back to her old hair color? Doesn't the Cheryl in Shattered Memories remind you of Heather? Just a thought, but maybe the Cheryl in this one is actually Heather, but that wouldn't explain Dahlia and lots of other things.

Post by **TheGhastlyGrinner** » 06 Dec 2009

Cheryl IS heather. At the end of sh1 alessa and cheryl are reborn as one. Heather.

Post by **Mephisto** » 06 Dec 2009

There are several threads like this, altough I suck at doing searchs.

By the way, you signature is kinda funny GhastlyGrinner.

Post by **simeonalo** » 06 Dec 2009

TheGhastlyGrinner wrote:Cheryl IS heather. At the end of sh1 alessa and cheryl are reborn as one. Heather.

Im talking about Shattered Memories. Is the Cheryl in Shattered Memories really Heather, considering that Dr. K says that everything before never happened? Did you finish the game? Im talking about a non-canon game, not facts I already know from SH1 and SH3 :\

Post by **Mephisto** » 06 Dec 2009

Ah, touchÃ©. I thought that you were talkin' about something else. As well as our friend with the clown sig did. My bad man, keep the thread alive, aye.

Post by **TheGhastlyGrinner** » 06 Dec 2009

I havnt played it but if it's harrys daughter then why wouldnt it be cheryl?

Post by **Mephisto** » 06 Dec 2009

To explain what I was thinking, yeah, I was thinking what Ghastly is. . .

Post by **Arsonist** » 06 Dec 2009

In what sense?

If you take this game as canon, you could interpret it as

PRIME_BBCODE_SPOILER_SHOW PRIME_BBCODE_SPOILER:

Silent Hill Origins, the original Silent Hill and Silent Hill 3 never happening and that they were just Cherylâ€™s different sessions at Dr Kâ€™s office

Or are you talking about something else?

I think I read somewhere that in Shattered Memories, Cherylâ€™s full name is; Cheryl Heather Mason.

Post by **TheGhastlyGrinner** » 06 Dec 2009

Mephisto wrote:There are several threads like this, altough I suck at doing searchs.

By the way, you signature is kinda funny GhastlyGrinner.

Yea it is lol, I came across the picture and had to do it. But anyway, I have yet to play this game because I will be waiting for its ps2 release. But from my understanding, Harry is the main character? And his daughter is cheryl which later becomes heather? So i'm not sure what you've seen that would change this.

Oh man, I think this thread has just ruined the next game for me.

Post by **Arsonist** » 06 Dec 2009

There is a big plot twist. I suggest you leave if you don't want to be completely and utterly spoiled.

Post by **TheGhastlyGrinner** » 06 Dec 2009

It seems to be too late. But this game being a non-cannon makes me feel a lot better. SPOILER TAGS PEOPLE!. Well if there are still multiple endings maybe I will be able to salvage some enjoyment in it.

Also, its been a while sense I starting posting on this thread again and forget how to mark spoilers. If anyone could fill me in again I would much appreciate that so I never spoil anyones fun

Post by **Arsonist** » 06 Dec 2009

To be fair, this is a spoiler forum, people are expected to post spoilers here, with, or without, spoiler tags.

Post by **Mephisto** » 06 Dec 2009

^Most likely without spoilers tags.
That was a close one, and I'm glad to say that nobody spoiled a thing for me

Post by **TheGhastlyGrinner** » 06 Dec 2009

I did not see that. fair enough. About the spoiler tag's how to? anyone?

Post by **Mephisto** » 06 Dec 2009

^But you're forgetting that this is a SM Spoiler section. People can talk about spoilers whenever they want.

Post by **PrescitedEntity** » 06 Dec 2009

"Shatterered Memories SPOILER FORUM
For people who have completed the game or are happy to be spoilerified"

That's the title for this forum. I think it's pretty obvious that there be spoilers here.

In other news, I caved.

Is that all the support there is for this being Heather instead of just a Cheryl with Heather as her middle name? I mean, I can't see Heather, post-SH3, deciding to go through this kind of therapy, to be honest. She didn't seem to doubt her SH experience's realness, and I don't think she'd readily seek out therapy, considering that she might end up blabbing about her past as though it was real, and getting diagnosed as vaguely insane...

Post by **simeonalo** » 06 Dec 2009

Anyways, so that means that ONLY Origins Happened, and SH1 and SH3 were Cheryl's sessions at the office? Weird. Anyone else noticed how sinister Dr. K can be some times in the game?

Let's go focus on the bad parts of High School.

Post by **Arsonist** » 06 Dec 2009

ONLY Origins Happened

PRIME_BBCODE_SPOILER_SHOW PRIME_BBCODE_SPOILER:

How so? SH:SM indicates that there most likely there is no supernatural power at play, just ravings of a madwoman. Besides, if origins did happen, how can Dahlia be Harry's wife

Post by **Prisonic Fairytale** » 06 Dec 2009

TheGhastlyGrinner wrote:I did not see that. fair enough. About the spoiler tag's how to? anyone?

Click on "post reply" instead of using the quick reply box. Highlight what you want to be in the spoiler box and click Spoiler.

Or just type out the tags, the word "spoiler" in [] and "spoiler" in [/] to end.

Post by **PrescitedEntity** » 06 Dec 2009

simeonalo wrote:Weird. Anyone else noticed how sinister Dr. K can be some times in the game?

Let's go focus on the bad parts of High School.

Maybe Heather got herself captured and is being brainwashed, LOL.

More seriously, some psychiatrists do that as a direct way of getting to the problem, or finding where the problem is.