Page 8 of 8
Posted: 10 Feb 2010
by Jack Frober
cascade88 wrote:
So... that means you can't discuss why you liked one better than the other? That's like saying I can't discuss why I like, well, oranges more than I care for apples.
Wow, actually when I wrote that post and left it like that, I had a feeling this would be your response. But still, I gave you a benefit of the doubt and yet you failed to see the point.
Read again.
Posted: 10 Feb 2010
by Dogg Thang
I can't help feeling it is you that failed to see his point. Sure, it's a common expression but people do have preferences when it comes to apples and oranges. And there's nothing wrong with discussing that.
If you don't want to discuss it, no problem.
But I, for one, see no point in trying to stifle discussion.
If you're curious, I prefer oranges. I'd give you my reasoning but it would be better suited to an off-topic post. This thread, as far as I can see, is for discussing which Silent Hill game people preferred.
Posted: 10 Feb 2010
by cascade88
Jack Frober wrote:cascade88 wrote:
So... that means you can't discuss why you liked one better than the other? That's like saying I can't discuss why I like, well, oranges more than I care for apples.
Wow, actually when I wrote that post and left it like that, I had a feeling this would be your response. But still, I gave you a benefit of the doubt and yet you failed to see the point.
Read again.
No, I got the point. My point is that this isn't a thread (or at least wasn't meant to be a thread) for comparing it. It was more of a "I like SH1 cos it had demons/cults." or "I like SHSM cos it didn't." With a little more elaboration, obviously. I don't see the problem with saying which one someone likes better.
Posted: 10 Feb 2010
by Jack Frober
cascade88 wrote:
I don't see the problem with saying which one someone likes better.
This thread is obviously about comparing games that are "supposed" to be similar due to that nice little word "re-imagining", but they're not. In fact, they are way too different. Hence the "apples and oranges" part.
Constant need for people to compare things just pisses me off. That's all.
Posted: 11 Feb 2010
by JuriDawn
Posts removed. Stay civil, guys.