In concept art of monsters in Silent Hill Downpour. That monster look like Murphy Dad or something.



So I come up with the theory that Prisoner Juggernaut could be related to Murphy family at some sort. It could be Murphy Uncle, Grandpa or Dad.
He are already dead and show up as a ghost manifestation in Overlook.
https://silenthill.fandom.com/wiki/Prisoner_Juggernaut

Also since I post this. I just notice something very cool about Prisoner Minion metal contraption. They actually look like metal spider. Take a look.

Or, they are just representations of his former prisoner inmates, or representations of himself as a prisoner. You know, as evidenced by the game itself. Simple as that, there's no need to make things complicated just for the sake of complicating things.

There is not a single mention of Murphy's relatives in the whole game. Non whatsoever. So why would you even consider the possibility of the prisoner monsters being a representation of Murphy's dad or uncle?

This is by far the most far-fetched theory I've read in a while.

Well screamer was related to murphy wife carol.
So jugernaut could be related like that as well. I think.

They are too separate monsters, where is your logic?

Besides, Murphy's wife is actually mentioned in the game.

It's like me saying that the Monocle Man is based on the mayor in Murphy's childhood town. Or that the screamer represents a very angry teacher that Murphy used to have in high school.

This is not called a theory, this is called fan fiction. That's what you're doing here.