Wait, wait, wait, WHAT?

Post by **AuraTwilight** » 22 Feb 2010

MMY wrote:>she's a post-mortem manifestation of Lisa's personality that's being maintained and influenced by Alessa.
No she's not. And there's absolutely no evidence to suggest as such.

I disagree, and the only evidence I've seen you provide is semantics on her final words.

Post by **The Adversary** » 22 Feb 2010

That's more evidence than "Alessa made her 'cuz she wanted a friend."

Post by **AuraTwilight** » 23 Feb 2010

Which isn't what was being proposed, but alright.

Post by **DamienPales** » 23 Feb 2010

I agree with MMY, I don't think Alessa created the Lisa that we see in the Otherworld. Why would she? Alessa and Lisa never communicate with each other. There isn't much sense in bringing someone to the Otherworld just to sit in a chair and ponder her existence.

However, I think Lisa has been dead since before the game. Masahiro Ito has an illustration of Lisa with a gunshot in her head. Perhaps Kaufmann shot her and she haunts the Otherworld as a ghost...

Post by **Mephisto** » 23 Feb 2010

Kauffman = hero.

Post by **NeoAquarius12** » 23 Feb 2010

Mephisto wrote:Kauffman = hero.

You have a skewed perception my friend. Kaufmann equals Teh Wurst! Lisa is a sweetheart and he corrupted her and prolly killed her, the bastard. Unless we're talking about Andy Kaufmann rather than Mikey... Andy IS a hero.

I know what you meant though. lol.

Post by **AuraTwilight** » 24 Feb 2010

DamienPales wrote:I agree with MMY, I don't think Alessa created the Lisa that we see in the Otherworld. Why would she? Alessa and Lisa never communicate with each other. There isn't much sense in bringing someone to the Otherworld just to sit in a chair and ponder her existence.

However, I think Lisa has been dead since before the game. Masahiro Ito has an illustration of Lisa with a gunshot in her head. Perhaps Kaufmann shot her and she haunts the Otherworld as a ghost...

Yes, but it does seem like she's the Hospital's equivalent of the Virun VII quest, according to some old theories around here, and she delivers useful information to Harry. Add that to the possibility that she may be an attempt to detain Harry from interrupting Alessa, and you have something that was ultimately worthy of creating, even if things didn't pan out to expectation.

Whether she's a construct or some ghost influenced by Alessa is irrelevant to me.