[ .[/quote]
No it's not. The Alessa from Silent Hill 1 is Alessa. Everything else is based off of our opinions. The Cheryl/Alessa from the movie seemed too depicted as evil and revenge seeking to me, and a change would be good.[/quote]
What are you even talking about? The movie version of SH1 has already been made, and Jodelle Ferland played that version of Cheryl/ Alessa. This is an indisputable fact. If you had issues with how Cheryl/ Alessa looked in the first film, then tough luck, because SHR is a direct sequel to the movie that featured Jodelle Ferland as these characters. Since Carmody and Bassett have all but said Heather is an older version of the child Rose goes home with, it makes zero sense to change her physical appearance because "she doesn't look enough like the character she already played in the first movie". Movie Cheryl has already been made and acted out, the only way that's going to change is if they remake the first movie, which isn't what Bassett is doing.[/quote]
Oh, I meant the Alessa from Silent Hill 1 THE GAME. Sorry for the confusion.

The Alessa from the game is irrelevant to the movie, though.

If I had to cast someone for Claudia Wolf, besides Carrie-Ann "Trinity" Moss, it'd be Mary Elizabeth McGlynn.

Not just because they look alike, either--Mary has a lovely voice, and did Claudia's voice-overs on the SH3 Soundtrack.

Other than Carrie-Ann Moss, I think Cate Blanchett would have possibly made a good Claudia.


As well as Laura Regan as Heather, other than Adelaide Clemens.

^ Plus, Laura Regan was the girl in all those fan-trailers for SH:R that RickRoll'd me, tricking me every time! It'd be, like, very apt.

^I'm assuming you're the confused person from the fan page this morning?