Re: Positive reactions on Facebook & IMDb
Posted: 03 Nov 2012
That's obviously not what anybody would have in mind for the dialogue, and definantly wasn't what I had in mind. Realistic dialogue doesn't mean just casually talking.tbonesays wrote:Shakespeare actually made fun of melodrama in a lot of his plays. Usually the character who uses the most sappy language ends up as the fool.Silent Fantasy wrote:But i'm am not someone who likes the shakespearian and melodramatic dialogue where it doesn't belong, and I definantly am not a fan of anime dialogue in most cases. So in a movie like this, or most any movie really, I won't like it. Maybe it's just me though.DistantJ wrote:I think he was trying to make it 'dreamlike'...
That's very possible and probobly should have been obvious to me. I guess it does work in that sense..somewhat. It's like you said yourself though, it still feels unnatural. I bet if the acting had been better during that scene, it may have played out just a bit better.
But here this scene was a pure man talking to his ghost wife, (Milton is a more appropriate reference). It cannot be a realistic down to earth conversation.
PRIME_BBCODE_SPOILER_SHOW PRIME_BBCODE_SPOILER:"Rose, When will you be home?"
"Yeah ya know I'm still trying to get time off from the Silent so like who knows? Remember Heather's birthday is coming up so get her a new jumpsuit for the cold weather, and remind her to keep her cell phone charged. Oh can you please fix the front door? The fogworld drafts keep blowing it open and we can't afford to buy new furniture every time you have to move from the cult."