the victim profiles indicate that it was eric walsh's birthday when he died, but the game indicates that it's walter sulivan's.

would have been pretty funny if there had been 10 candles

Well, someone correct me if I'm wrong, but it must have been a birthday, because I think I remember the room being mildly decorated for it, and a gift being on the table or somewhere around there.

If I'm wrong, sorry, and I have no idea why I'd remember it that way if... it wasn't.

But anyhow, don't you have to put a candle (or candles) on the cake? Candles only go on a cake when it's someone's birthday, as far as I know...

No, your absolutely right.