Eileen's acts....
Moderator: Moderators
-
- Just Passing Through
- Posts: 41
- Joined: 15 Mar 2006
- Location: Nowhere
-
- Just Passing Through
- Posts: 41
- Joined: 15 Mar 2006
- Location: Nowhere
I think it was just to ease the tension in SH4 because really without little scenes like that the game would be one big horror/mystery/thriller game. Well thats what type of game it is but like I said it takes you out of a tense/shaken mode and lets you see a little humor before all the haunting, etc. start picking up...
Sometimes I think that people look into things too much, not only on this thread but on others. Not everything is going to hold importance to the story line, characters, or previous games alot of it is out of fun and people just make it harder than it really is...
Sometimes I think that people look into things too much, not only on this thread but on others. Not everything is going to hold importance to the story line, characters, or previous games alot of it is out of fun and people just make it harder than it really is...
Wow... what a read.
First of all I haven't been to this forum in quite a while. How you all doing?
Okay, much to talk about.
I totally enjoy trying to find things that have subtle meanings in games/movies/plays. I read most the theories and here's the conclusion I have come too.
I believe if you look at the game from two different angles either way of playing them could be fun. If I look at it from a 'Eileen has seen him a few times in the hallway and thinks he's cute' way playing the game is like playing a blooming love story, from the first look, to the first real interaction. The contrast of this idea is interesting. I'm a bit silly, but it kinda reminds me of "While You Were Sleeping." She was kinda excited (I know they don't show this in the game, but just read the rest of my post) to see him everyday, but didn't really wanna go out of her way to talk to him or anything and then something huge happens that slam their worlds together. (Granted the rest of the story did a different turn, psh, chick flick anyway) ANYWHO! The idea of her even just finding him a bit attractive makes the game a bit more fun for me to play. Though I understand where the same idea wouldn't be found by other people. And that is their own opinion and I understand that.
However, until the other day when talking about this same concept, I didn't even really come to that conclusion about Eileen and Henry. I was always under the impression (Though the hopeless romantic in me tells me otherwise now) that when she dropped the groceries and she said the 'lucky' line she was talking about how she hoped her 'luck' kinda like her 'smoothness' would be better... meaning she hopes she isn't as clumsy at the party. Her looking at the door may be just because she is kinda curious about the room. Hey, if I walked past this room that made wierd sounds I would look at it everytime too.
The theory that perhaps she was going to ask Henry to the party is a kinda fun theory as well. When I think about it now she could have been asking him as a date or just because she wanted to see if he needed out of the house since she hadn't seen him a while. Probably hoping he might come to the door. (You know that what happened before hadn't happened again.) If she dropped her groceries she could have easily been hitting herself for being so stupid in front of a stranger (had he answered the door)
If you don't believe in the asking theory, I've got another theory why she may have walked by the door. However due to the fact that I haven't fully beaten the game I won't go into that small theory. Heck, Mike could have thought she was cute as well and had asked her to drop him off groceries so he never had to leave his porno collection behind.
As for the bee thing. My sister is deathy afraid of bees and has been known to almost run away from them when they are around. Although I view my sister to be 'retarded' I know she's not and some people really do have fears like that of somethings... including the common smaller then a quarter bee.
I always felt that perhaps she is using something that isn't a broom to clean up whatever mess she left behind, during the infamous 'no broom' cleaning scene.
As for the love story as the game progresses, well I don't know it all yet. But hell if some halfway attractive guy from next door came bounding in to rescue me and killed a bunch of scary monsters to protect me while risking his own neck, I would fall for him pretty easy. (That reminds me of Shaun of the Dead tee-hee) However, perhaps there is no love story. Its all up to the players perspective and how they wish to look at the game.
However, when it comes to Eileen in general, I would have to say watching her behind the peeholes is really more so aimed at keeping the player understanding the feeling of being trapped into a world he cannot control with the real world so close to his fingertips. She represents what the character wants to much at the begining of the game, and that is to get out and live a simple life. She may laze around or attack bees in the hallway and we may find it odd, but to be a person trapped in a room with no way back to a normal world, what he wouldn't give for having no life and 'watching brooms.'
Okay... that was really long, but I couldn't summarize all the thoughts going through my mind when I read the post.
*Goes and sits down and shuts up*
First of all I haven't been to this forum in quite a while. How you all doing?
Okay, much to talk about.
I totally enjoy trying to find things that have subtle meanings in games/movies/plays. I read most the theories and here's the conclusion I have come too.
I believe if you look at the game from two different angles either way of playing them could be fun. If I look at it from a 'Eileen has seen him a few times in the hallway and thinks he's cute' way playing the game is like playing a blooming love story, from the first look, to the first real interaction. The contrast of this idea is interesting. I'm a bit silly, but it kinda reminds me of "While You Were Sleeping." She was kinda excited (I know they don't show this in the game, but just read the rest of my post) to see him everyday, but didn't really wanna go out of her way to talk to him or anything and then something huge happens that slam their worlds together. (Granted the rest of the story did a different turn, psh, chick flick anyway) ANYWHO! The idea of her even just finding him a bit attractive makes the game a bit more fun for me to play. Though I understand where the same idea wouldn't be found by other people. And that is their own opinion and I understand that.
However, until the other day when talking about this same concept, I didn't even really come to that conclusion about Eileen and Henry. I was always under the impression (Though the hopeless romantic in me tells me otherwise now) that when she dropped the groceries and she said the 'lucky' line she was talking about how she hoped her 'luck' kinda like her 'smoothness' would be better... meaning she hopes she isn't as clumsy at the party. Her looking at the door may be just because she is kinda curious about the room. Hey, if I walked past this room that made wierd sounds I would look at it everytime too.
The theory that perhaps she was going to ask Henry to the party is a kinda fun theory as well. When I think about it now she could have been asking him as a date or just because she wanted to see if he needed out of the house since she hadn't seen him a while. Probably hoping he might come to the door. (You know that what happened before hadn't happened again.) If she dropped her groceries she could have easily been hitting herself for being so stupid in front of a stranger (had he answered the door)
If you don't believe in the asking theory, I've got another theory why she may have walked by the door. However due to the fact that I haven't fully beaten the game I won't go into that small theory. Heck, Mike could have thought she was cute as well and had asked her to drop him off groceries so he never had to leave his porno collection behind.
PRIME_BBCODE_SPOILER_SHOW PRIME_BBCODE_SPOILER:
She could have also been checking on him too seeing as he has been skinned to death and also not coming out of his apartment
I always felt that perhaps she is using something that isn't a broom to clean up whatever mess she left behind, during the infamous 'no broom' cleaning scene.
As for the love story as the game progresses, well I don't know it all yet. But hell if some halfway attractive guy from next door came bounding in to rescue me and killed a bunch of scary monsters to protect me while risking his own neck, I would fall for him pretty easy. (That reminds me of Shaun of the Dead tee-hee) However, perhaps there is no love story. Its all up to the players perspective and how they wish to look at the game.
However, when it comes to Eileen in general, I would have to say watching her behind the peeholes is really more so aimed at keeping the player understanding the feeling of being trapped into a world he cannot control with the real world so close to his fingertips. She represents what the character wants to much at the begining of the game, and that is to get out and live a simple life. She may laze around or attack bees in the hallway and we may find it odd, but to be a person trapped in a room with no way back to a normal world, what he wouldn't give for having no life and 'watching brooms.'
Okay... that was really long, but I couldn't summarize all the thoughts going through my mind when I read the post.
*Goes and sits down and shuts up*
- KageReneko
- Subway Guard
- Posts: 1561
- Joined: 02 Aug 2005
- Gender: Male
- Location: My own personal hell
- The Adversary
- RESPECT
- Posts: 20095
- Joined: 19 Jul 2003
- Location: #lfk
- Contact:
>She could have also been checking on him too seeing as he has been skinned to death
Mike wasn't "skinned to death": Richard embarrassed him by skinning his clothes off, and by beating him up. Also, that happened a long time, when Walter was just a kid--some twenty+ years ago; Mike probably doesn't even live there any longer.
>Well, we are talking about a girl who...
That doesn't make her socially inept.
Mike wasn't "skinned to death": Richard embarrassed him by skinning his clothes off, and by beating him up. Also, that happened a long time, when Walter was just a kid--some twenty+ years ago; Mike probably doesn't even live there any longer.
>Well, we are talking about a girl who...
That doesn't make her socially inept.
This post is the property of its author and is not to be used elsewhere without explicit permission from the author.
. . . AND THAT'S THAT.
. . . AND THAT'S THAT.
Ahh... see, I haven't played the game all the way through thus I didn't get that impression yet. I just listened to the tape and saw the paintings and thought otherwise. It makes more sense now to be honest, thanks for clearing that up.the Adversary wrote:>She could have also been checking on him too seeing as he has been skinned to death
Mike wasn't "skinned to death": Richard embarrassed him by skinning his clothes off, and by beating him up. Also, that happened a long time, when Walter was just a kid--some twenty+ years ago; Mike probably doesn't even live there any longer.
If that is the case, which I was pretty sure it was... Perhaps the person that lives down there now did need some groceries, like an older person. Giving her reason to walk past the room.
I would also like to apologize for the randomness of my post. It was hard to keep a straight thought in my head so late at night
Hmmm...hummer wrote:on one part she looks at the hole and notices you and then turns around and caries on laughing and claping retardedly. I think she needs her head cheacking
I didn't think that anyone could really notice you in the hole except Walter. Besides, peepholes are hard to see from the other side of a door. I don't remember that scene...
One of the things I kinda liked about SH4 was the way it wasn't like, a Final Fantasy love story. It had every possibility to be and they could have like, kissed before the boss fight all poetic like, but it didn't and therefore was...well, more like Silent Hill than Final Fantasy with monsters.
Not saying there is or isn't anything, since it's totally possible; people don't always show their emotions on the outside, so it's really up to interpretation. However...I think towards the end they were at least friends. Nothing wrong with that, it wasn't necessary to beat us over the head with their undying love or something.
Btw, I don't mean that anyone was saying they had undying love...or whatever. This wasn't directed at anyone's side of the argument xD
As for the (sort of) original topic, yeah, Eileen acted a little weird, but honestly, if someone was watching you all day you might act weird too. She's alone in her apartment or (supposedly) in the hallway. Sometimes you do stupid things, especially alone and occasionally in public. It made her a human character, albeit one who had a few extra problems to deal with (ie - getting her ass handed to her 1000 times).
Not saying there is or isn't anything, since it's totally possible; people don't always show their emotions on the outside, so it's really up to interpretation. However...I think towards the end they were at least friends. Nothing wrong with that, it wasn't necessary to beat us over the head with their undying love or something.
Btw, I don't mean that anyone was saying they had undying love...or whatever. This wasn't directed at anyone's side of the argument xD
As for the (sort of) original topic, yeah, Eileen acted a little weird, but honestly, if someone was watching you all day you might act weird too. She's alone in her apartment or (supposedly) in the hallway. Sometimes you do stupid things, especially alone and occasionally in public. It made her a human character, albeit one who had a few extra problems to deal with (ie - getting her ass handed to her 1000 times).
-
- Gravedigger
- Posts: 477
- Joined: 27 Mar 2006
- Mis Krist.
- Historical Society Historian
- Posts: 12943
- Joined: 27 Aug 2003
- Location: The Wand'ring Wood
I'm doing a necro-bump here, but I wanted to address something Glazarus was adamant about when arguing in favour of Eileen liking Henry.
I'm replaying The Room, and according to Glazarus, Eileen looks at Henry's door--in fact he says "a direct look" at it--when she says "I hope my luck changes before the party," inferring that she's talking about HIM and her secret desire to go to the party with Henry. And I'm happy to say this is utter crap because not only is Eileen not looking at the peephole at all when she says this, she's walking away from the door, having spared only one glance at it when she said, "Oh man."
But apparently that "Oh man" is a declaration of her love.
I'm replaying The Room, and according to Glazarus, Eileen looks at Henry's door--in fact he says "a direct look" at it--when she says "I hope my luck changes before the party," inferring that she's talking about HIM and her secret desire to go to the party with Henry. And I'm happy to say this is utter crap because not only is Eileen not looking at the peephole at all when she says this, she's walking away from the door, having spared only one glance at it when she said, "Oh man."
But apparently that "Oh man" is a declaration of her love.
I'm not dead yet, dammit.
- Nurse Babz
- My Bestsellers Clerk
- Posts: 302
- Joined: 30 Apr 2006
- Location: Is Florida considered the Dirty South or East Coast?
- The Adversary
- RESPECT
- Posts: 20095
- Joined: 19 Jul 2003
- Location: #lfk
- Contact:
St. Thomas wrote:Originally posted Thu 20 Jul, 2006 6:30 pm
Exactly. Doesn't mean "Henry's so~~~o dreamy but how I am supposed to ask him to the party now?, after I've embarrassed myself Oh Noes!!!"
Because, you know, that's dumb.
It's funny because I love Friends . . . I'm watching it right now in fact.St. Thomas wrote:>Is Eyleen watching the TV
Yes. Probably something dumb like Friends.
And no one ever bothered to show me proof that Eileen was looking for a "date" specifically--that she actually makes "a comment about needing a date for the party." Anybody got a magic copy of the script? 'cuz mine's still not saying it. Randall? Come on, I know you love to argue with me.
This post is the property of its author and is not to be used elsewhere without explicit permission from the author.
. . . AND THAT'S THAT.
. . . AND THAT'S THAT.
I always got the feeling that she knew that Henry was peeking and she wanted to tell us (the audience) that there's something more about her than what meets the eye.Krist. wrote:I'm doing a necro-bump here, but I wanted to address something Glazarus was adamant about when arguing in favour of Eileen liking Henry.
I'm replaying The Room, and according to Glazarus, Eileen looks at Henry's door--in fact he says "a direct look" at it--when she says "I hope my luck changes before the party," inferring that she's talking about HIM and her secret desire to go to the party with Henry. And I'm happy to say this is utter crap because not only is Eileen not looking at the peephole at all when she says this, she's walking away from the door, having spared only one glance at it when she said, "Oh man."
But apparently that "Oh man" is a declaration of her love.
Like if she was taunting Henry, or trying to scare him.
- The Adversary
- RESPECT
- Posts: 20095
- Joined: 19 Jul 2003
- Location: #lfk
- Contact:
>maybe eileen was wanting him to go to the party.
Physical appearance has nothing to do with the discussion: there's nothing to suggest they were interested in one another until the end of the game.
>she didnt even go to the party, did she?
No, I don't think she made it. She was invited to the hospital unconsciously instead. . . .
Physical appearance has nothing to do with the discussion: there's nothing to suggest they were interested in one another until the end of the game.
>she didnt even go to the party, did she?
No, I don't think she made it. She was invited to the hospital unconsciously instead. . . .
This post is the property of its author and is not to be used elsewhere without explicit permission from the author.
. . . AND THAT'S THAT.
. . . AND THAT'S THAT.