Silent Hill 4 ‘and He got angry.’ *possible SPOILERS*

[Aric - The Reaper]

Remember how Henry got Eileen to read those strange writings and they kept talking about ‘Him’ or ‘He’? Well while playing SH3 they talked about how violent Leonard was to Claudia and to others, well for some reason (after finishing the hospital in SH3) I got the idea that Leonard was the one young Walter was writing about. If you can recall (those that have played the game) he talked about getting smacked, well Leonard did abuse Claudia, maybe it is him!

What do you think? Remember this is my personal opinion and thought.

(if there is a post of this already, I'm sorry, it's hard finding the same subject even with search)

[Mephisto]

I think those scriptures were about God. But since the God is a woman in the eyes of many believers I don't really know. But it can be a possibility, Dahlia's God was male for all that we know. (Yes, it had tits, but check out for Baphomet and you'll know what I mean. It's kind of a male deity, the breasts mean the fertility or something. . .)

[sumcaker]

Walter trashed a petstore, killed all the animals and killed the owner beacause a dog from the store bit him, if he got beat by Leonard, I would of thought that Leonard would of got the worst of Walter's treatment.

[AuraTwilight]

Lots of men were angry and abusive in Walter's life.

[The Adversary]

The "he" alluded to in Walter's diary is Andrew DeSalvo.

[Mephisto]

^ Oh yeah, when I was replying I was thinking about things like "If we go out the Master is sad" that's why I said it was God. . . The master, you know.

[carneeval]

At some points it seemed he was speaking of Jimmy Stone, he too beat the children (Funny, I never actually thought of Andrew)

[The Adversary]

>At some points it seemed he was speaking of Jimmy Stone, he too beat the children
Source?

[Mephisto]

Jimmy Stone never abused the children by beating'em up. He only "brainwashed" them with the help of George Rosten (is that the right name? I can't remember it.) and others.

[simeonalo]

^ Right. It was Andrew who abused Walter. MAYBE Leonard, it's not confirmed.

[Mephisto]

Leonard Wolf was from another sect at the time Walter was a child. Leonard was from the same sect as Dahlia if I'm not wrong, they only met the children once and it was when Dahlia told the story about "The Descent of the Holy Mother" to Walter. Leonard never beated Walter, only Claudia as far as we know.

[Aric - The Reaper]

all interesting ideas and thoughts. so many possibilites!

[Droo]

Dahlia visited Wish House more than once. "The important lady came again."

[Aric - The Reaper]

i remember that too, it could have been her or young Alessa?

[The Sanity Assassin]

Young Alessa? I don't think so. There is actually a note on the ground in Wish House saying something like "Have you found Alessa?" and "How is Walter doing?"
So it's probably Dahlia who came for a visit

Walter trashed a petstore, killed all the animals and killed the owner beacause a dog from the store bit him,

Didn't he unintentionally hurt a little cat when he was younger?
Source: Garlands victim file
Maybe Garland yelled at him and therefore Walter, at this time still a boy, was scared? The first page of the victim file also says that Steve was only kind to animals. Now imagine what happens when someone hurts one of his precious pets?

[Aric - The Reaper]

I agree with you, Water went through a lot of suffering.

[The Adversary]

>"Have you found Alessa?"
This note alludes to Heather.

[Aric - The Reaper]

it could be Leonard and Claudia could be the important lady