Are Cluadia and Dahlia related

[Mr.FLOOT]

I tried searching but couldnt find anything.

Me and a friend are debating weather Daliah and Claudia are related because I'm sure that Claudia was Alessa's childhood friend but my friend seems to think that Claudia and Alessa were sisters.

Can anyone clear this up for me?

Thanks

[B5160-R]

They are most definitely not sisters. Very close friends, yes, but not sisters.

[Whoomp]

You can say that they are "sisters" since they are in the same clan but not related by blood.

[alone in the town]

You can also say they were like sisters. Yunno, like the game does.

[Squarehead]

And you could say Dahlia and Claudia were related by insanity.

[Moosefrenzy]

Dahlia and Claudia are both part of The Order, of the Holy Woman Sect. That's their relation.

[AuraTwilight]

They're also tied together by botanical symbolism. ^_^

[BloodRedLion]

Or you could just simply say they weren't related, and eliminate the potential for confusion, which seems to be quite large for some people on this board.

[Disciple of Claudia]

They weren't related by Dahlia was probably Claudia's mentor.

[solidus]

Or you could just simply say they weren't related, and eliminate the potential for confusion, which seems to be quite large for some people on this board.

Where's the fun in that?
....
wasent it mentioned ingame that they were sisters? im not sure as i havnt played the game start to finish in a while.

[The Adversary]

Alessa gave Claudia a birthday card that read "I love you like you're my sister." (paraphrase)

[freako104]

Alessa gave Claudia a birthday card that read "I love you like you're my sister." (paraphrase)

I honestly do not recall that scene, only that Claudia and Alessa were best friends. When does the card get mentioned? And that being said, that would say that Dahlia and Claudia are NOT related. They can love each other as family but that is it

[extreme-nero]

Alessa gave Claudia a birthday card that read "I love you like you're my sister." (paraphrase)

I honestly do not recall that scene, only that Claudia and Alessa were best friends. When does the card get mentioned? And that being said, that would say that Dahlia and Claudia are NOT related. They can love each other as family but that is it

from the 3rd games when you read the card in claudia's room

[freako104]

I figured that much, but I havent played 3 since my PS2 broke down and stopped working several months ago. thus I can't remember where in the game it is fully mentioned. As in where, and what was going on at the time

[der Morgenstern Czigany]

far as i recall, alessa & claudia were childhood friends. Claudia is part of the Order and is considered a "sister" or nun of the order.

[The Adversary]

>thus I can't remember where in the game it is fully mentioned.
It's in the Chapel, in Claudia's bedroom. She has the birthday card kept on her desk (or shelf, I forget). Heather mentions how She's kept it all these years, round twenty-three, since it was for her sixth birthday, to illustrate further the dynamic between Claudia & Alessa's relationship.

[toadstool]

i think they knew each other, but i didnt see or hear of any evidence of any kinship between them

[Watchdog]

What, other than the card, and practically every line of Claudia's dialogue?

[Rehkyt]

Ok They ARE NOT SISTERS. Just childhood friends. The Is NOTHING in The Game that say other wise.

[Fan from Silent Hill]

Ok They ARE NOT SISTERS. Just childhood friends. The Is NOTHING in The Game that say other wise.

Yeah, but Claudia is blabering it all the time. She says it every 15 minutes... Well it doesn't mean it's true, but still, why would she make something like that up?