When Heather... (possible spoilers)

Post by **Archaeis** » 21 Jan 2006

When Heather kills the god at the end of th game, presuming you go by the first ending, is it all over? The god trying to manifest itself was the source of all the shit going on in Silent Hill wasn't it?

Post by **Mis Krist.** » 21 Jan 2006

Silent Hill 2 provides evidence that the town itself is now tainted, so it's kind of expanded beyond the matters of God trying to be born. (What evidence is that? The fact that Silent Hill 2 exists.. The story has nothing to do with God or ressurrecting Her and the town still shifts to the Otherside.) I think it's safe to say that all of it is not over, since those other worlds still exist.

We won't know for sure until Silent Hill 5 is released.

Post by **Mr.Death** » 21 Jan 2006

I'd say no,killing God in Silent Hill 3 probably didn't cure the town,the evil still exists,forever.Even a gray alien couldn't make it go away.There's got to be something,a force,behind the town,whether it was manifested by Alessa or not.But that's just my opinion.

Post by **emptimass** » 22 Jan 2006

If you look into the lore of SH you woill find that the town has
pretty much been on the fritz since man settled there. I think
that it is just tainted ground. I would of course love to
know more about the history of SH beyond what is already given.
I have always seen SH as kind of a gateway, a portal and
a place that strong emotion can be made manifest.
There were plenty of things that happened way before Allessa.
She just magnified things a little.

Anonymous · Post by **Anonymous** » 23 Jan 2006

Krist. wrote:Silent Hill 2 provides evidence that the town itself is now tainted, so it's kind of expanded beyond the matters of God trying to be born. (What evidence is that? The fact that Silent Hill 2 exists.. The story has nothing to do with God or ressurrecting Her and the town still shifts to the Otherside.) I think it's safe to say that all of it is not over, since those other worlds still exist.

We won't know for sure until Silent Hill 5 is released.

I dont think that SH2's otherworld has anything to do with Alessa. She is not the only thing that causes mystic things in the town and I dont believe she caused any of them in Silent hill 2. Have you read the SH lore? It tells about indian sacred ground and shit like that if im not mistaken.

Also, the otherworld in SH2 is different, its defenitely not created or manifested by Alessa.

Post by **The Adversary** » 23 Jan 2006

>I dont think that SH2's otherworld has anything to do with Alessa.
Krist. didn't suggest anything of the sort.

Post by **Mis Krist.** » 23 Jan 2006

Dane wrote:
Krist. wrote:Silent Hill 2 provides evidence that the town itself is now tainted, so it's kind of expanded beyond the matters of God trying to be born. (What evidence is that? The fact that Silent Hill 2 exists.. The story has nothing to do with God or ressurrecting Her and the town still shifts to the Otherside.) I think it's safe to say that all of it is not over, since those other worlds still exist.

We won't know for sure until Silent Hill 5 is released.
I dont think that SH2's otherworld has anything to do with Alessa. She is not the only thing that causes mystic things in the town and I dont believe she caused any of them in Silent hill 2. Have you read the SH lore? It tells about indian sacred ground and shit like that if im not mistaken.

Also, the otherworld in SH2 is different, its defenitely not created or manifested by Alessa.

I think you misunderstood me.. I never suggested that at all. And I don't know how you think I did.

Post by **Mr.Death** » 23 Jan 2006

Hmmmm.Allessa,no?Yeah,I guess the town was already tainted.I usually had,and have,my own interpretations of the game.

Anonymous · Post by **Anonymous** » 23 Jan 2006

I didnt say she did, i just said i didnt thought Alessa had any influence at all. Just adding to the matter she commented, thats all.

Post by **Jedah** » 23 Jan 2006

Mr.Death wrote: Hmmmm.Allessa,no?Yeah,I guess the town was already tainted.I usually had,and have,my own interpretations of the game.

The towns been tainted for a long time. Long before Allessa or the cult even came to SH.

Here is a nice link to SH timeline. Again, keep in mind what you see there it's not 100% fact, but close enough to give you an idea that the town as been the way it is for a long time:

http://silenthilltears.125mb.com/centuryone.htm

Post by **Loveless_Dogg** » 23 Jan 2006

I was hoping that when Heather turned to face the camera during the ending, she was going too find a baby lying on the ground......
.........Then I was hoping she was going to walk over to it and stomp it to death.

Post by **Archaeis** » 03 Feb 2006

Do you think Heather would kill a baby?

Post by **Dr. Gordon** » 03 Feb 2006

she tried to at the end of the third game.

Post by **Archaeis** » 03 Feb 2006

What do you mean?

Post by **Dr. Gordon** » 03 Feb 2006

if you played the game, you'd know.

Post by **Archaeis** » 03 Feb 2006

I have played it through more times than any of the others. If you're talking about when she defeats the god and then turns around, then I know what you mean. But, they cut the crying out of this version. So, there's no evidence that she actually killed it.

Post by **Dr. Gordon** » 03 Feb 2006

Archaeis wrote:Do you think Heather would kill a baby?

your question.

My answer is she did try when she uses the pendant toward the end of the game.

also cool it with posting. one a minute since 6:00 is a little shady.

Post by **Archaeis** » 03 Feb 2006

Well, she knew that was the god, not an actual baby.

Post by **Mis Krist.** » 04 Jun 2007

Just like she'd know that the baby the God would turn into - as it did for Harry - would still be the god.

Ergo, yes, I think she'd kill it. Or just walk away from it.

Anonymous · Post by **Anonymous** » 08 Jun 2007

The thing that Heather killed was just one God that the cult was trying to bring about. The Yellow and Red Gods (Xuchilpaba and Lobsel Vith) don't have anything to do with Alessa and co.
I doubt if any normal person could kill a baby, evil or not, so she would probly just walk off and leave it for Valtiel to do whatever.