I definitely agree with this...not so much the rip off of PH, but in the sense that his design was so bland and generic and it's true that he looks like one of the cult members from Homecoming.The Bogeyman could very well be one of the worst monsters/characters ever made for a Silent Hill game. Not only does it rip off Pyramid Head, but also the cult members.
And while i do understand his whole angle with him wearing a raincoat in conjunction with the title and events within the game, i just wanted his design to be a bit more creative....his design alone could be seen in other countless forms of media...movies, comics..other video games etc...