Well, someone posted this on another forum and I tweaked it a bit. List away my fellow... I can't think of anything clever... oh well... *EDIT* I changed "Favorite Quote" to "Cutscene" to make it easier.

Favorite Silent Hill game:
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game:
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack:
Favorite Main Protagonist:
Favorite Main Antagonist:
Favorite Supporting Character:
Favorite Monster/Enemy:
Scariest Monster/Enemy:
Favorite Weapon:
Favorite Location/Room:
Favorite Cutscene:
Favorite Quote:
K, i'll go first...

Favorite Silent Hill game: Silent Hill 3
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: Silent Hill 4
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: Silent Hill 2
Favorite Main Protagonist: Heather
Favorite Main Antagonist: Claudia I guess...
Favorite Supporting Character: Angela
Favorite Monster/Enemy: Valtiel
Scariest Monster/Enemy: Mumblers
Favorite Weapon: Shotgun
Favorite Location/Room: Brookhaven Hospital
Favorite Cutscene: "Stairs Of Fire" in SH2 where James encounters Angela for the last time.

Favorite Silent Hill game: Silent Hill 2(This was hard, because I really like all of them)
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: Don't have one
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: Silent Hill 2
Favorite Main Protagonist: James Sunderland
Favorite Main Antagonist: Pyramid Head
Favorite Supporting Character: Cybil
Favorite Monster/Enemy: Pyramid Head
Scariest Monster/Enemy: The Unseen thing in Toluca Prison
Favorite Weapon: The good ol' trusty shotgun
Favorite Location/Room: Silent Hill 4's 'Room'
Favorite Cutscene: Maria in the cell in SH2

Favorite Silent Hill game: 2 or 4 (dont know why i liked playin but i liked playin it)
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: 4 (its a love/hate relationship)
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: 2 or 4 (that 1 theme song in 4 got me hooked)
Favorite Main Protagonist: henry (game mae him look like a moron... its funny)
Favorite Main Antagonist: PH (butcher guy with big knife and red pointed head)
Favorite Supporting Character: maria (the bustop hooker look is coming BACK!)
Favorite Monster/Enemy: those lil kids with claw hands in SH1 (i forget name)
Scariest Monster/Enemy: same as above or the closer (.... woot)
Favorite Weapon: wooden board with nail (its the way you can say just nail it baby)
Favorite Location/Room: the apartments (in SH2)
Favorite Cutscene: SH1 bloopers

Hahaha I am happy to see another person who has the same love/hate relationship with Silent Hill 4 that I do, lol.

Favorite Silent Hill game: Silent Hill 2
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: Silent Hill 4
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: Silent Hill 2
Favorite Main Protagonist: Heather
Favorite Main Antagonist: Walter Sullivan
Favorite Supporting Character: Douglas
Favorite Monster/Enemy: Closer
Scariest Monster/Enemy: Those stupid damn ghosts in SH1
Favorite Weapon: Emergency Hammer
Favorite Location/Room: Pete's Bowl-o-Rama
Favorite Cutscene: Room 312

Favorite Silent Hill game: Silent Hill 2
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: Silent Hill 4
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: Silent Hill 1
Favorite Main Protagonist: James
Favorite Main Antagonist: Dalea
Favorite Supporting Character: Thats a hard one, I have to think about it
Favorite Monster/Enemy: Pyramid Head
Scariest Monster/Enemy: Those screeching things from Silent Hill 3, I can't remember what there called
Favorite Weapon: SH1 Katina
Favorite Location/Room: Another hard one
Favorite Cutscene: The First monster you see in SH2, were James finds the radio

Favorite Silent Hill game: Silent Hill 2
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: Silent Hill 4
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: Silent Hill 4
Favorite Main Protagonist: James Sunderland
Favorite Main Antagonist: Pyramid Head
Favorite Supporting Character: Eddie Dombrowski
Favorite Monster/Enemy: Mandarin
Scariest Monster/Enemy: Stalkers
Favorite Weapon: Emergency Hammer (SH1)
Favorite Location/Room: Big Head room (SH4)
Favorite Cutscene: James's Realization... Apartment 312

Favorite Silent Hill game: Silent Hill 2
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: Silent Hill
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: Silent Hill 2
Favorite Main Protagonist: Heather (SH3)
Favorite Main Antagonist: Silent Hill 2's... it's a spoiler.
Favorite Supporting Character: Maria
Favorite Monster/Enemy: Silent Hill 2's final boss... it's a spoiler.
Scariest Monster/Enemy: Closer (SH3)
Favorite Weapon: Baseball Bat (SH4)
Favorite Location/Room: Burning Staircase (SH2)
Favorite Cutscene: "Anyway!? What do you mean anyway!?"

Favorite Silent Hill game: Silent Hill 2
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: Silent Hill 1. Only because I cannot play with 3D controls
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: Oh, I like them all =D If I had to pick, Silent Hill 2
Favorite Main Protagonist: James Sunderland
Favorite Main Antagonist: Claudia Wolf and Walter Sullivan
Favorite Supporting Character: Angela Orosco
Favorite Monster/Enemy: Double-Head and The One Truth demon
Scariest Monster/Enemy: The ghosts from Silent Hill 4 would always drive me into a panic XD
Favorite Weapon: Unlimited Sub-Machine gun XD Or, when I'm playing fair, that trusty ol' pipe that pops up in all the games
Favorite Location/Room: The wheelchair-behind-glass in Silent Hill 3. A close second is Brookhaven from both 2 and 3
Favorite Cutscene: Oh, tough one. I'd have to say the opening cutscene that played You're Not Here from Silent Hill 3 because that was the absolute first impression of the whole Silent Hill universe

Favorite Silent Hill game: Silent Hill 2
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: Silent Hill 3
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: Silent Hill 2
Favorite Main Protagonist:James Sunderland
Favorite Main Antagonist: Pyramid Head
Favorite Supporting Character: Maria
Favorite Monster/Enemy: Table monsters in SH2
Scariest Monster/Enemy: Phead
Favorite Weapon: steel pipe from SH2 or that axe from SH4
Favorite Location/Room: Lakeview hotel
Favorite Cutscene: Room 312 cutscene

Favorite Silent Hill game: Silent Hill 1 & 2
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: Silent Hill 4. What can I say???
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: mmmm, can't really say... SH2?
Favorite Main Protagonist: James Sunderland
Favorite Main Antagonist: Dahlia
Favorite Monster/Enemy: errr.... the final boss from SH3
Scariest Monster/Enemy: The ghost child in SH1
Favorite Weapon: The good old shotgun
Favorite Location/Room: Any room inside the Hotel in SH2
Favorite Cutscene: Lemme see.... the cutscene when Harry finds Lisa

Favorite Silent Hill game: Silent Hill 4
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: Silent Hill 3
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: Silent Hill 2
Favorite Main Protagonist: James
Favorite Main Antagonist: I'm gonna say Pyramid Head, much fun!
Favorite Supporting Character: Maria
Favorite Monster/Enemy: Blobble Head Nurses
Scariest Monster/Enemy: Walter
Favorite Weapon: shot gun
Favorite Location/Room: I dunno where it is but the room in SH4 where the room is upside down..hope I wasnt imagining things lol
Favorite Cutscene:*Spoiler maybe* James before he fights the two PH's

Favorite Silent Hill game: Silent Hill 4
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: Silent Hill 1
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: Silent Hill 2
Favorite Main Protagonist: Heather
Favorite Main Antagonist: Walter
Favorite Supporting Character: Eileen
Favorite Monster/Enemy: Mumbler
Scariest Monster/Enemy: PH
Favorite Weapon: Axe
Favorite Location/Room: Hospital in 1
Favorite Cutscene: Sacrements Ending in 4

Favorite Silent Hill game: SH2
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: SH3
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: SH2
Favorite Main Protagonist: James
Favorite Main Antagonist: Maria
Favorite Supporting Character: Eileen
Favorite Monster/Enemy: PH/Nurses
Scariest Monster/Enemy: Mandarins
Favorite Weapon: Handgun, baby!
Favorite Location/Room: Lakeview Hotel/Brookhaven Hosp.
Favorite Cutscene: Maria/James Prison and

[spoiler]Cynthia's death.[/spoiler]

Favorite Silent Hill game: Silent Hill 1.
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: None. I like all of them for different reasons.
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: SH1.
Favorite Main Protagonist: Harry.
Favorite Main Antagonist: Dahlia.
Favorite Supporting Character: Lisa.
Favorite Monster/Enemy: Mumblers.
Scariest Monster/Enemy: Mumblers.
Favorite Weapon: Emergency hammer.
Favorite Location/Room: Midwich Elementary School.
Favorite Cutscene: After the boss fight [spoiler](or lack thereof) with Cybil.[/spoiler]
[/spoiler]

Favorite Silent Hill game: SH3
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: SH4
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: SH2
Favorite Main Protagonist: Heather
Favorite Main Antagonist: Claudia
Favorite Supporting Character: Vincent (*drools*)
Favorite Monster/Enemy: Pyramid Head
Scariest Monster/Enemy: Walter Sullivan
Favorite Weapon: The steel pipe (all games), the handgun (all games), the rusty axe (SH4) and the emergency hammer (SH1)
Favorite Location/Room: Brookhaven Hospital
Favorite Cutscene: The one after Heather turns the faucet

~

May I add another catagory?

Favorite Silent Hill song(s): "A World of Madness" (SH2), "Wounded Warsong" (SH4), "Breeze- In Monochrome Night" (SH3), and "Fear of the Dark" (SH1)

Favorite Silent Hill game: SH1
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: SH4
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: SH1
Favorite Main Protagonist: Harry
Favorite Main Antagonist: Claudia
Favorite Supporting Character: Lisa
Favorite Monster/Enemy: Pyramid Head
Scariest Monster/Enemy: Mumblers
Favorite Weapon: Shotgun
Favorite Location/Room: Alchemilla Hospital
Favorite Cutscene: Lisa's death

Favorite Silent Hill game: SH2 or SH3
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: SH4
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: SH2
Favorite Main Protagonist: James Sunderland! waii!!
Favorite Main Antagonist: Pyramid Head or Claudia
Favorite Supporting Character: Laura
Favorite Monster/Enemy: Nurses
Scariest Monster/Enemy:" "
Favorite Weapon: Unlimited SMG!!!
Favorite Location/Room: The bleeding mirror in Silent Hill 3 where Heather becomes Alessa
Favorite Cutscene: Where James views the video tape and realizes what he has done.

Favorite Silent Hill game: Silent Hill 2
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game: Silent Hill 4: The Room
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack: Silent Hill 2
Favorite Main Protagonist: Henry Townshend (Because of "What the hell?!" )
Favorite Main Antagonist: Pyramid Head
Favorite Supporting Character: Cybil
Favorite Monster/Enemy: Lying Creature (this is REALLY hard. I'm not very sure about this)
Scariest Monster/Enemy: Silent Hill 2 Nurse of the Clawfinger in SH1(and the Mumbler)
Favorite Weapon: Shotgun, steel pipe or The Great Knife
Favorite Location/Room: Must be Midwich Elementary(SH1) or the Brookhaven (SH2)
Favorite Cutscene: Pyramid Head first personal encounter. Because he does a hilarious sound when he......eats (theehee) the Lying Creature in the Blue Creek Stairway. [/b]

Favorite Silent Hill game:Silent Hill 1
Least Favorite Silent Hill Game:Silent Hill 3
Favorite Silent Hill soundtrack:Silent Hill 1
Favorite Main Protagonist:James Sunderland
Favorite Main Antagonist:Dahlia Gillespie
Favorite Supporting Character:Lisa Garland
Favorite Monster/Enemy:Zombie Children
Scariest Monster/Enemy:That woman with long black hair in SH4
Favorite Weapon:Emergency Hammer
Favorite Location/Room:The Resort Area (not sure why though)
Favorite Cutscene:Lisa - the diary scene with the bloody face