Silent Hill Heaven

I don't want complete reimaginings of either SH1 or SH3 - especially not SH1. I also don't want the stories to me merged into one single game. Although I'm fully aware of SH3's faults as a lackluster drag and for its unoriginality, its faults should not hamper a full remake of SH1. Merging the two ...

Very good. It also makes sense for Angela, who by any measure, isn't guilty of anything but defending herself but she believes she deserves to everything and that doesn't change by the end of the game. Angela is by far and away the largest catalyst for my theory. When James steps into Angela's othe...

I feel like there has to be some reason the Town wants to "punish" James as well. BoLM quote “Power of the Town Just what is the effect of the mysterious power of this town that was revered as a sacred place? Originally Silent Hill was a holy place to the area's former inhabitants. It wou...

I like to think James is stuck in a cycle until he is sorta tricked into doing the Rebirth ending by the nefarious forces of the town. Alas, much like Pet Cemetery, Walter Sullivan and any other Occult resurrection, it's not going to be what he thinks it is. I also like the loop theory as well but ...

The Adversary wrote: ↑27 Dec 2024 Just for reference: Dahlia isn't an alien robot. She's just a robot. I'm not sure where the alien part came from.

I also have more to say on the matter, just can't at the moment because my house is on fire.

I hope everything is ok

No, no part of that loop theory will come into play for me. I'm not an evangelist by nature, so you can take or leave the loop theory as you please. But I'm not going to assume it's just a given (because it's really not). Just like I'm not going to assume it's a given that Dahlia is an alien robot,...

That's what I thought.

Question here is, and I understand your distain for the loop theory. Will part of that loop theory come in play at all? I ask that because your premise is coming from parts of the Remake that wasn't part of the OG.

Apologies here Disrupticon, I may have interrupted the premise incorrectly.

I was under the impression that you were building this theory on the Remake alone.

Unused assets are one thing, but if that is James' voice, modulated, in the "Director's" recording then said assets hold water IMO. Developers obviously know what they leave in the game will be discovered, and in a game like this it wouldn't be a surprise if it was left there on purpose. I...

I am very intriqued here Disrupticon.......

I will try to listen to the Dircetors recordings again, I have no doubt that it must be James.

Let me guess...

Patient No. 0050 is James
Patient No. 0130 is Angela
and
Patient No. 0090 is Eddie

Correct?

My issue with this theory is that Angela is a lot further in her journey than James when he meets her in the cemetary. She knows James isn't "lost". I am not saying that parts of her Otherworld may not be her home. I mean it makes total sense. But I am inclined to believe that everywhere s...

So this puzzle that can be found in the Woodside Apartments has been the subject of intrigue for some people. https://cdn.staticneo.com/ew/thumb/b/b6/Silent-hill-2-remake-108-golden-apple-handle.jpg/363px-Silent-hill-2-remake-108-golden-apple-handle.jpg This is supposedly called the Hand of Fatima ...

Bumped the game did not win anything. He'll blades ratings were much lower but it beat out the Remake twice

Ignorance is Bliss

My take on James from the Remake, since he seems like an older version of James, could very well be the James that ends up with one of the 2 below endings from the original Silent Hill 2. (Sans Dog and UFO endings) The Maria ending Rebirth In the 2 above endings, James falls deeper into his delusion...

Apologies here, lurking and enjoying this conversation.... A couple of questions alone in the town. 1. If James is called because of his guilt, how can the town's power have an "ulterior motive" for his presence? ie: Ritual of Holy Assumption. 2. For this thread, are you suggesting that th...

I am more inclined to believe that James reliving this nightmare repeatedly has more to do with certain endings he gets. It has more to do with "why" he killed Mary. I exclude UFO and Dog ending here. Stillness, Leave and In Water seem to close things out for James. As the "why" ...

The Adversary wrote: ↑04 Dec 2024
It has the eye from the Halo of the Sun. James also picks up the book of Crimson Ceremony there.

I have already gotten the Rebirth ending.... LOL

I was rushing to get the other trophies as well.

Thanks !

TerryRed wrote: ↑04 Dec 2024 Freshly dug up grave in the graveyard. This gets covered and has a new headstone on NewGame+.

The clock in the checkout room in Lakeview Hotel is the only clock that is not stuck at the same time as all other clocks.

I did not notice these 2.

Is there writing on the new head stone?

4 words...

I'm not your Mary.