Silent Hill 5: Cons (What you don't like)

Poor Alex ... his momma don't seem to like him much. We wonder why in here ...

Moderator: Moderators

Post Reply
pink_isnt_well000
Historical Society Historian
Posts: 7464
Joined: 09 Jun 2005
Gender: Female
Location: Kentucky

Silent Hill 5: Cons (What you don't like)

Post by pink_isnt_well000 »

This thread is for cons, not pros. There is another thread dedicated to the pros. All posts made here that should be posted in the pros thread will be removed.


This is for EVERYONE'S sanity.

Please do not come into this thread only to say "I wish everyone would stop hating on this game". If you're going to "hate" this is the place to do so! But, please be advised that we will remove (and give warnings when needed) any posts that are considered flamming. Be respectful, this thread can be locked down at any time, keep that in mind.


The following are topics that are now closed. Please do not repeat what you have said in these threads here. USE these threads as a references.


http://www.silenthillforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=13089

http://www.silenthillforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=13259

http://www.silenthillforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=13346

http://www.silenthillforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=13175

http://www.silenthillforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=13234
User avatar
sizzleguy05
Just Passing Through
Posts: 21
Joined: 10 Dec 2005
Location: Austin, Texas
Contact:

Post by sizzleguy05 »

The only con I can think of from what I can see is that the fact that they are using a lot of what we already saw in the movie in this new game (i.e twitching nurses, the bathroom transformation sequence). I'm a little hesitant that its just gonna be a new story in that same Silent Hill we saw in the movie....I think people would get sick of that.
"I met this six year old child, with this blank, pale, emotionless face...and the blackest eyes, the DEVIL'S eyes." -Dr. Loomis on Michael Myers, HALLOWEEN


See you on the flip side,

SIZZLE
sh#1fan
Historical Society Historian
Posts: 3005
Joined: 14 Jan 2004
Gender: Male
Location: Moon base #25

Post by sh#1fan »

sizzleguy05 wrote:The only con I can think of from what I can see is that the fact that they are using a lot of what we already saw in the movie in this new game (i.e twitching nurses, the bathroom transformation sequence). I'm a little hesitant that its just gonna be a new story in that same Silent Hill we saw in the movie....I think people would get sick of that.
I have to agree 100% there~
I love how the game looks, but them taking the ash in the fog (wich has nothing to do with the silent hill game), and the nurses, and the pealing walls seems so dumb.
This is there chance to spred there wings and show what they can do.... not just what they can copie.
oO?
User avatar
KLGChaos
My Bestsellers Clerk
Posts: 413
Joined: 25 Sep 2003
Location: Right behind you...

Post by KLGChaos »

Yeah, but here's to hoping that they come up with something much more original as well. I liked how they showed that they can graphically copy the movie, but I'd like to see that kept to as much of a minimum as possible.
I'm offended by political correctness.
Smokey
Gravedigger
Posts: 552
Joined: 05 Jul 2004
Location: Orlando, Florida

Post by Smokey »

Well, I do worry, but I think if done tactfully it could still be good. I mean, the visual effects for the movie are pretty cool - even though the movie sucked - and it's really neat to see it done in game, but yeah I'm afraid that they will go the way of the movie which is to have a shit story.

Also, they seem to really like the movie's character model of Pyramid Head - I am afraid he will show up in the game...I am really afraid that pyramid head in any manifestation will show up in the game. I love him, but he's exclusive to SH2 and needs to stay that way.
If you can read this, I'll kill you.
User avatar
Ayu
My Bestsellers Clerk
Posts: 335
Joined: 23 Sep 2007
Location: Happy land
Contact:

Post by Ayu »

I have to agree with all of you. It's great they're putting this stuff into the game, but I hope they can keep it original. Especially since, as a site linked in one of the closed threads:
Among others, Akira Yamaoka has said that the story and "theme" of Silent Hill V will be similar to Silent Hill 2. Fans of the series have been quick to notice that Alex's surname, Shepherd, is the same as James Sunderland's wife in Silent hill 2, Mary Shepherd-Sunderland. Perhaps the relation to Silent Hill 2 was more literal than we thought? Or maybe its one of those "connections" between Silent Hills which the fans love. We'll find out soon enough.
[url=http://sejant.deviantart.com/][img]http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y97/NightElves/dance-5.gif[/img][/url]
crucifix
Historical Society Historian
Posts: 2121
Joined: 24 Jun 2007

Post by crucifix »

i too was put off by the whole "peeling walls in the bathroom as the last stall opens and a monster comes out"... exactly the way it happened in the movie.

i hope there isn't some big escort thing with elle you have to do like in SH4, either.
no longer active. thanks for the memories.
User avatar
Doo-glas
Brookhaven Receptionist
Posts: 945
Joined: 25 Sep 2007

Post by Doo-glas »

my only worries are that the art style and story may not be able to match the pure insanity of the previous games(cuz what's more insane that the Japanese? :P )


oh yeah and PLEASE don't add any stuff from the movie(like saying Silent Hill is a mining town) because that would totally screw up the games continuity
Breaka
Brookhaven Receptionist
Posts: 886
Joined: 16 Apr 2006
Location: Bath/London UK
Contact:

Post by Breaka »

I really don't think that it actually look that much like Silent Hill. I know its early days, but all the textures and monsters just look so clean and sharp. Needs a lot more grime, filth and ruffness.
Double Helix, I spit on your grave! :evil:
User avatar
Ayu
My Bestsellers Clerk
Posts: 335
Joined: 23 Sep 2007
Location: Happy land
Contact:

Post by Ayu »

Breaka wrote:I really don't think that it actually look that much like Silent Hill. I know its early days, but all the textures and monsters just look so clean and sharp. Needs a lot more grime, filth and ruffness.
So what you're trying to say is... Needs more gore? o.o
[url=http://sejant.deviantart.com/][img]http://i3.photobucket.com/albums/y97/NightElves/dance-5.gif[/img][/url]
User avatar
emehlen
Just Passing Through
Posts: 24
Joined: 18 May 2007
Location: Silent Hill

Post by emehlen »

The only thing I dont like about SHV is that it is an American developer... they dont understand Japanese psychological horror, if they do then it will still be Americans trying to mimic the real deal. Team Silent should be working on this. They made the damn series what it is! It should be the same people who made SH2... even down to the same damn janitor! I want the feel of SH2 to come back.

Also, I guess I'd agree with others about the likeness with the movie... we saw it already, it sucked, and we want originality.
User avatar
evanpeters85
Just Passing Through
Posts: 6
Joined: 04 Oct 2007
Location: North Bend NE

Post by evanpeters85 »

I know it's a early build of the game so this issue will be most likely cleared up but I really hope that the grapics get vamped up from what we've seen in the trailers, and I also hope that there won't be "The lock is broken, I can't open the door" messages, even though it's already in one of the trailers
-Insert cool signature picture or quote here-
User avatar
evanpeters85
Just Passing Through
Posts: 6
Joined: 04 Oct 2007
Location: North Bend NE

Post by evanpeters85 »

Sorry I mean "The lock is broken, I can't open the door" messages 20 times in a row
-Insert cool signature picture or quote here-
User avatar
themudgopher
Cafe5to2 Waitress
Posts: 227
Joined: 19 Jun 2007
Location: Neely's.
Contact:

Post by themudgopher »

^yeah, they could just say that once and then say "nope. door's stuck" after that.
i'm okay with a return of pyramid head, as long as it's not modeled after the movie OR sh2. some new mutant PH would be awesome.
[img]http://i69.photobucket.com/albums/i42/themudgopher/sig.jpg[/img]
User avatar
evanpeters85
Just Passing Through
Posts: 6
Joined: 04 Oct 2007
Location: North Bend NE

Post by evanpeters85 »

Oh a new pyramid head would be awesome, and I agree with you themudgopher, a new pyramid head that would be insane
-Insert cool signature picture or quote here-
Loveless_Dogg
Historical Society Historian
Posts: 3526
Joined: 01 Mar 2004
Gender: Male
Location: Waco, Texas
Contact:

Post by Loveless_Dogg »

Silent Hill has pretty much been a japanese style horror game influenced by american style horror......SH5 is a japanese style horror game influenced by american style horror...made by an American team....yeah, I'm really gonna like this one... >. >
Value your failures more than your successes. Successes only last until someone screws them up. Failures are forever. She left...and...I'm lost.
User avatar
Xigz
Hope House Careworker
Posts: 673
Joined: 20 Jun 2006
Location: Minnesota

Post by Xigz »

Sullivan, Walter wrote:Silent Hill has pretty much been a japanese style horror game influenced by american style horror......SH5 is a japanese style horror game influenced by american style horror...made by an American team....yeah, I'm really gonna like this one... >. >
It seems to be to be for of a American Style horror influenced by Japanese in SHV's case.
[b]I'm constant now, and useful too.
I know my eyes cannot see through.[/b]
User avatar
Justicar333
Just Passing Through
Posts: 122
Joined: 02 May 2006

Post by Justicar333 »

Don't like the way their treating the nurses. Every incarnation should be shaped by the perception of the one Silent Hill draws from. In SH2 and the movie it made sense. James was sexually nuts, and Alessa would have viewed the adult female nurses as some type of sexual pinacle compared to her burned child body. Thus in both cases the nurses have exagerated boobs/legs.

Now in 5, they just ripped em, rather than shapping them to fit Alex's mind. Maybe he viewed nurses like that, pinup girls. But it would be very nice if he didn't, just to avoid repeating what's already been done twice. (or three times, think someone said Origins did the same thing?) Same thing about them flocking to light.. why in the hell do they do that in 5? The nurses are some of the most dangerous enemies in Silent Hill. Alessa's strong influence on the town left them bound to the hospital, where they shall probably exist as long as the town does.

Every game they get stronger, smarter. Yet now their idiots that can't avoid a table lamp? I'm going to be infuriated if they are turned into nothing more than puzzle pieces. The lumping them in one area ruined that part of the movie. Don't make the same mistake with the game.
User avatar
Glazarus
Historical Society Historian
Posts: 2132
Joined: 14 Oct 2004
Location: In the Cave of Rendezvous

Post by Glazarus »

The cons, and these are serious cons:

1 The collective is making the graphics "dynamic" instead of "static"
This will take away the "arty" feeling of the images. The light and enviroment will not feel like a Rembrant painting and the graphics will feel more technical then artistic. The previous games utilized the "making something ugly, beautiful" style that directors like David Fincher made with films like Se7en and Fight Club. The dynamic graphic engine will create some massive epic effects but is that really what Silent Hill is about? It's especially interesting that games like Resident Evil, that is known for it's action approach to horror, uses static graphics for their next game; Resident Evil 5. As a sidenote to that, the early images of Resident Evil 5 looked far better then the early images of Silent Hill 5, mainly because of the fact that Resident Evil 5 uses static instead of dynamic graphics.
What should The Collective do?
I'm hoping for a total change into static graphics to go back to the artistic feel that is a core element of Silent Hill. If they have to have the dynamic engine, they need to make a kind of mix, or else the images will become dead and boring.

2 The close connection/resemblence to the "Silent Hill Movie"
Having this connection and resemblence to things in the Silent Hill movie speaks heavely about how low the creativity is at The Collective. It's one thing to be inspired by other works of art and popular culture and to steal or use an exact copy of something. Best example is the video of the nurse coming out of the toilet booth, that is an exact copy from the scene in the movie.
I mean, what is The Collective thinking here? That approach is clearly out of making the franchise appeal to an audience that isn't embracing works of art and instead want the cool features that the movie had. Nurses are also exactly the same as in the movie. The previous games even had differences between the nurses in each game.
There are so many clichés and uncreative things that could be spotted from what The Collective said in interviews and what could be seen in the videos.
What should The Collective do?
Take away everything that is a direct steal from the movie. This game isn't "Silent Hill: The movie: The game", it's Silent Hill 5, a new story, were things should be new and original. I would have complained even if they used copies of previous monsters in the serie, so it's not just about the connection to the movie. They need to use a better art-director that has the same approach to design as teamsilent. It doesn't have to be the same as teamsilent, but it needs to be the same approach to art.

3 Combat system should not be a focus
The Collective have stated numerous times that they will not focus on combat; still, in the interview, they got all excited when questions came to the combat system. Looking back at the "making of" docs about Silent Hill 2 and 3, teamsilent never spoke of combat, because the main focus was the Story and "psychology" of the game. The atmosphere has always been more important then the combat. The dynamic graphics and the way they talk about the combat, it's clear that it will have more action this time. It will be more "epic", then close to the characters. Silent Hill is all about characters, story and atmosphere. That is the three core elements that is combined into what Silent Hill is known for. Going away from that isn't creative and original, it's making Silent Hill something it's not. Originality and creativity should come from versions of those three core elements. You can make something totally new without loosing them. I could make a movie with the same core elements and the movie will feel like Silent Hill, while not being it.
What should The Collective do?
Go through the gameplay and compare it to the atmosphere of the previous games. If the atmosphere is more actionpaced, they need to change the combat system and reduce it.

4 This is speculation, but, The Collective seems to not focus on storytelling
Having a good story isn't the same as telling a good story. The storytelling should be the main focus. Silent Hill is mostly based upon how the characters behave between eachother, their backstories and the atmosphere of the cutscenes. The slow pace of the storytelling is of a Tarkovsky quality and I have little hope in that The Collective draws atmospheric inspiration from movies like that. I believe that The Collective will focus on a faster tempo, which will strangle the pace and storytelling.
One important thing when talking Silent Hill is "Silence is more important then sounds". Akira said this about the sounddesign, but it's also very important for storytelling. What characters don't say is more important then what they say; it's a basis for all good storytellers in cinema and theatre. If the dialogue is written without this important storytelling part, it will loose it's soul and life. It will become a cliché.
What should The Collective do?
Collaborate with a teamsilent director or a director that isn't from the gaming world.
Silent Hill 2 hired a storytelling advisor on this part and that showed. The Collective should do the same. Silent Hill is all about the story. It's more about using the interactive parts to create a higher level of horror, then creating just a game.

I'm basing these things on anylizing the interviews, what they said and how they said it, rather then just basing it on the gameplay videos.

I have more opinions, but those are more details then core elements.
[url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S0ZO3_UaUJs&fmt=22][img]http://img440.imageshack.us/img440/4855/psalm21banner.jpg[/img][/url]
Breaka
Brookhaven Receptionist
Posts: 886
Joined: 16 Apr 2006
Location: Bath/London UK
Contact:

Post by Breaka »

The main character looks like he is some kind of robot. He only has one facial expression, and in that crappy toliet scene he just stands there motionless like an egg.

He sure aint no Heather Mason!
Double Helix, I spit on your grave! :evil:
Post Reply